Tile vs Shingle Roofs: Poinciana Pro Roofers Help You Decide

When it comes to roofing in Central Florida, homeowners often face a tough decision: tile or shingles? At Poinciana Pro Roofers, we've worked on hundreds of homes across the region, and the tile vs shingle roofs debate is one we’re asked about almost every week.

Each roofing system offers distinct advantages, and what works best for one home might not suit another. That’s why we’ve created this detailed guide to help you understand the pros, cons, costs, and ideal use cases for both roofing materials—specifically for homes in Poinciana, FL.

Tile vs Shingle Roofs: Poinciana Pro Roofers Break Down the Difference

Let’s start by comparing the two most popular roofing materials in Florida head-to-head:

Tile Roofs-

Materials: Usually made from clay, concrete, or composite tiles

Appearance: Classic Mediterranean or Spanish-style look with excellent curb appeal

Durability: Extremely durable—can last 40–50+ years

Weather Resistance: Excellent in extreme heat, humidity, and wind

Fire Resistance: Very high

Cost: Higher upfront cost due to labor and material, but long-term savings

Weight: Heavier, may require structural reinforcement

Best for: Homeowners looking for longevity, energy efficiency, and a high-end finish

Shingle Roofs-

Materials: Most commonly asphalt (either 3-tab or architectural shingles)

Appearance: Traditional, clean look with a wide variety of colors and textures

Durability: 15–30 years depending on quality and installation

Weather Resistance: Good, but vulnerable to wind uplift if not installed correctly

Fire Resistance: Moderate

Cost: Much more affordable and easier to install

Weight: Lightweight, works well with most structures

Best for: Budget-conscious homeowners, quick replacements, rental properties

How Does Florida’s Weather Affect Your Choice?

Poinciana homeowners know: Florida isn’t easy on roofs. We get intense heat, year-round UV exposure, afternoon downpours, and storm season winds. So the material you choose has to hold up under pressure.

At Poinciana Pro Roofers, we’ve seen tile roofs outperform in terms of lifespan and heat resistance. Tile reflects more sunlight and creates a thermal barrier, which can reduce your indoor cooling needs. That means lower energy bills over time.

However, shingle roofs—especially high-quality architectural shingles—are still widely used and trusted throughout Central Florida. With proper attic ventilation and storm-nailing installation, they can perform surprisingly well and are easier and faster to replace after hurricane damage.

Click here to learn about our hurricane-ready shingle installations

Explore our tile roofing systems for Florida homes

Maintenance & Repairs

Tile roofs may require fewer full replacements, but cracked or broken tiles should be fixed promptly to avoid water intrusion. Luckily, individual tiles can be replaced without tearing off the whole roof.

Shingle roofs, on the other hand, may need more frequent inspections and repairs—especially after storms. Shingles can curl, blister, or get torn off entirely. Still, repairs are usually simpler and less expensive.

At Poinciana Pro Roofers, we provide regular roof inspections, preventative maintenance, and repair services for both tile and shingle systems.

👉 Schedule your roof inspection today

Cost Comparison: Tile vs Shingle Roofs

Here’s a rough breakdown of the cost per 100 sq. ft. of roofing (1 roofing "square"):

• Tile Roofing: $700 – $1,000 per square (installed)

• Architectural Shingles: $350 – $500 per square (installed)

• 3-Tab Shingles: $250 – $350 per square (installed)

Yes, tile costs more upfront—but with a 40+ year lifespan, you may only replace it once in a lifetime. Shingles, however, might need to be replaced every 15–25 years depending on the material and weather impact.

HOA & Aesthetic Considerations in Poinciana

Some communities in Poinciana have HOA rules that dictate roof appearance. If you live in a Mediterranean-style development, your HOA may require tile roofing to maintain visual consistency. On the other hand, some neighborhoods opt for shingles to keep costs down for residents.

Not sure about your HOA guidelines? Poinciana Pro Roofers can help you navigate the approval process and provide estimates for both materials.

Our Final Take: Tile vs Shingle Roofs Poinciana Pro Roofers Recommendation

So—tile or shingles?

Here’s how we help our clients decide:

• Budget-sensitive or short-term stay? Go with architectural shingles

• Forever home or upscale neighborhood? Invest in tile

• Live in a storm-prone area? Both are viable—just make sure installation is done by local pros who understand Florida codes

• Worried about upkeep? Tile is lower maintenance in the long run

  
  

When comparing Tile vs Shingle Roofs, Poinciana Pro Roofers always prioritizes long-term value, structural compatibility, and local weather conditions to guide your roofing decision.

Still unsure? No problem. Poinciana Pro Roofers offers free consultations, honest guidance, and skilled installation for both shingle and tile roofs.

📞 Contact our team today or request a free quote to get started with a roof that suits your home, your climate, and your wallet.